Editor’s Note: There is no formally recognised speciality of “Aesthetic Doctor”; it is merely a colloquial term often used to refer to a GP or dentist with a special interest in aesthetic medicine.
Patients today are more informed than ever, yet one area that still causes confusion is understanding who is qualified to perform which aesthetic treatments and procedures. As non-surgical procedures become more advanced and surgical procedures more visible online, the lines can appear blurred. In this expert-led feature, Paola Chellew speaks with voices in South Africa’s aesthetic and surgical community to bring clarity to the roles, training, and scope of aesthetic doctors and plastic surgeons, helping patients make informed and safe decisions.
Contributing to this discussion are Dr Shahien Dollie, general practitioner (GP with an interest in Aesthetic Medicine) and Treasurer of Aesthetic and Anti-Ageing Medicine Society of South Africa (AAMSSA); Dr Dirk Lazarus, plastic surgeon and President of Association of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons of Southern Africa (APRASSA); and Dr Edward Ngwenya, plastic surgeon, APRASSA member, and Committee Member of AAMSSA.



For context, AAMSSA represents medical doctors practising aesthetic medicine, with a focus on ethical, evidence-based, non-surgical treatments. APRASSA represents specialist plastic and reconstructive surgeons and serves as a key professional body for surgical standards, training, and patient safety in Southern Africa.


Understanding the difference between non-surgical and surgical scopes
While both aesthetic doctors and plastic surgeons play important roles in aesthetic medicine, their training pathways and scopes of practice differ significantly.
The distinction becomes particularly important when patients are considering treatments that may cross from non-surgical into surgical territory.
Aesthetic Doctors (GPs with a Special Interest in Aesthetics)
(Answered by Dr Shahien Dollie)
1. Training and Qualifications
What training and qualifications are required to practise aesthetic medicine in South Africa?
- MBChB- Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery
- Full registration with the HPCSA (Health Professions Council of South Africa) as an independent medical practitioner.
- Aesthetic medical training, which, while not yet formally regulated by the HPCSA as a separate speciality, is essential for safe practice. Many aesthetic medical doctors complete:
- Aesthetic medical diplomas/certificates (from the Foundation for Professional Development, or the American Academy of Aesthetic Medicine).
- Product-specific and device-specific training that is recognised by the industry and CPD compliant.
2. Professional Membership
Which professional bodies should an aesthetic doctor ideally belong to, and why does this matter?
Mandatory:
The HPCSA (Health Professions Council of South Africa) which is the statutory regulator of all health professions in South Africa.
Recommended:
- AAMSSA (Aesthetic and Anti-Aging Medicine Society of South Africa), which supports evidence-based aesthetic practice and promotes ethical guidelines.
- CMAC (Complications in Medical Aesthetics Collaborative), which provides peer support, complication-management guidance, and access to expert networks.
- IMCAS (International Course on Aging Science Academy) / DASIL (Dermatology, Aesthetics, and Surgery International League) / other relevant international organisations, which provide extensive tools for ongoing education, support and development in the field of aesthetic medicine and surgery.
Membership signals commitment to ethics, continuous training, and accountability.
3. Scope of Practice
According to the rules of these organisations, which procedures are you permitted to perform as an aesthetic doctor? Are GPs allowed to perform cosmetic surgical procedures such as liposuction or blepharoplasty?
The HPCSA, as the ultimate regulator of all medical professions, maintains that General Practitioners may only perform professional acts for which they have adequate education, training, and experience. Although there may be some GPs that have demonstrated competency in certain cosmetic surgical procedures to the HPCSA, in general, Aesthetic Medical Doctors are generally restricted to non-surgical procedures, including:
- Botulinum toxin injections
- Tissue fillers and biostimulators
- Energy-based device therapy (lasers, RF, ultrasound, IPL, plasma)
- Chemical Peels
- Threads
- PRP, PRF, Exosome, microneedling, mesotherapy
- Minor office-based procedures
4. Verification and Ethics
How can patients check that their aesthetic doctor is properly trained, registered, and compliant with HPCSA ethical standards?
Patients should:
- Check HPCSA registration via the official lookup portal (https://hpcsaonline.custhelp.com/app/i_reg_form).
- Confirm membership with AAMSSA (https://aestheticdoctors.co.za/find-a-doctor/) or other recognised organisations.
- Review training certificates (which reputable practitioners openly provide).
- Ensure treatments occur in a properly equipped medical environment with clear consent processes.
- Observe adherence to HPCSA ethical rules regarding advertising, claims, and patient communication.
Transparency is a key marker of ethical practice.
5. Collaboration with Surgeons
If a patient is considering cosmetic surgery, is it appropriate for them to seek advice from their general practitioner (with an interest in aesthetics)?
Yes, aesthetic doctors can:
- Provide guidance on whether surgery or non-surgical options are more appropriate.
- Help set realistic expectations.
- Refer the patient to a fully qualified plastic and reconstructive surgeon when surgical intervention is needed.
- Coordinate pre- and post-treatment care when appropriate.
This collaborative approach supports safer and more informed decision-making.
6. Safety and Risks
What are the main risks when aesthetic treatments are performed by non-medical persons?
When aesthetic treatments are performed by non-medical persons (beauty therapists, lay injectors, unregistered providers), the risks escalate dramatically.
These include:
- Misdiagnosis and poor patient selection.
- Increased risk of severe adverse events, such as vascular occlusion (a medical emergency when filler is injected into a blood vessel), which may lead to tissue necrosis and even blindness from fillers.
- Infections due to improper sterilisation and inappropriate procedure settings.
- Inability to manage emergencies (anaphylaxis, lidocaine toxicity, vascular compromise).
- Use of unregulated products.
- Lack of accountability (no HPCSA oversight).
In short, aesthetic medicine must be performed by trained medical professionals to ensure patient safety.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons
(Answered by Dr Dirk Lazarus and Dr Edward Ngwenya)
1. Training and Qualifications
What formal qualifications and training are required to become a plastic and reconstructive surgeon in South Africa?
Dr Lazarus outlines the pathway:
- MBChB – Fully qualified doctor, internship (1 year), and community service (2 years) completed
- FCS – Fellow of the College of Surgeons of South Africa, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. This is required to become a registered specialist plastic surgeon. Three exams need to be passed while doing practical surgical training in a teaching hospital:
- The primary: anatomy, physiology, pathology, and basic sciences
- The Intermediate: surgical principles, including intensive care, trauma, surgical specialities across the board from neurosurgery to orthopaedics, etc. Trainees, registrars, are working as junior surgeons during this time, and it may take 3-4 or more years to complete this part of one’s surgical training.
- FCS – the final exam, after a further 4-5 years of specific plastic surgical training at a teaching hospital and now sometimes with private practice surgeons. The FCS is tough. Many universities now also require trainees to complete a master’s degree (MMed) as well.
- Once one has obtained FCS (Plast & Recon Surg), many young surgeons will then go on to do fellowships for further training. Fellowships may be in specific areas of plastic surgery: cosmetics, microsurgery, hand surgery, paediatric plastic surgery, burns, etc.
- Once plastic surgeons are admitted to APRASSA – see here, they are encouraged to enrol in APRASSA’s mentorship program for at least a year.
In summary, 3 onerous exams and usually about 8 years of training after med school, internship and comm service. The average age of qualification is about 36.

2. Professional Membership
What does it signify when a surgeon is registered with APRASSA (Association of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons of South Africa)?
According to Dr Ngwenya:
APRASSA, like all other specialist societies, is a voluntary member body that represents the vast majority of specialist plastic surgeons in South Africa.
As each application is scrutinised accordingly, motivated by two member colleagues, and voted for at an AGM for ratification, it provides a credible database for any general public citizen searching for a credible registered plastic surgeon in good standing.
3. Surgical Scope
Which procedures fall exclusively within the domain of a qualified plastic surgeon?
Dr Lazarus is clear:
Plastic surgeons manage the full range of reconstructive and cosmetic surgery — from head to toe.
Examples include:
- Reconstruction after cancer surgery or trauma
- Congenital anomaly correction (e.g., cleft lip/palate)
- Microsurgery
- Breast reconstruction
- Facial reconstruction
- Complex laceration repair
- Transplant-level reconstruction (e.g., face or hand)
- And more – see here
Reconstructive is about the function and form of the body.
Cosmetic surgery enhances appearance and has a basis in reconstructive surgery. The two go hand in hand. Reconstructive techniques are used in cosmetic surgery and vice versa.
Dr Ngwenya concurs:
Plastic Surgery is a diverse surgical speciality consisting of reconstructive and aesthetic (cosmetic) surgery. Thus, any surgical procedure related to same falls within the domain of a Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon (Reconstruction of deformities from trauma, cancer, birth defects; and Cosmetic Procedures that seek to enhance one’s aesthetic appearance).
4. Title Usage
If a practitioner calls themselves a “cosmetic surgeon,” what should patients understand about that title? Is this the same as a plastic and reconstructive surgeon?
Dr Ngwenya explains:
There is no formally recognised title of a “Cosmetic Surgeon” in South Africa. A Plastic Surgeon might use that term to refer to their particular interest in the cosmetic aspect of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.
It is also a term that has been wrongly used by some non-qualified practitioners, who perform cosmetic/aesthetic procedures such as botulinum toxin, fillers, threads, etc, which can confuse the public.
Therefore, it is imperative for a general member of the public to not merely look at such “self-proclaimed non-official titles” but instead look at the core formal qualifications that one who claims to be a “Cosmetic Surgeon” has.
If a practitioner does not hold a Fellowship (FC Plast Surg) from the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa (CMSA) and/or a Masters in Plastic Surgery (MMed) from a recognised University in South Africa, and duly registered with the Health Professions Council Of South Africa, then they are not qualified to perform that which they claim competency in, and are in contravention of HPCSA rule 21.
Dr Lazarus adds:
The Health Professions Council mandates that cosmetic surgery should only be performed by specialist surgeons: plastic and reconstructive surgeons.
Other surgical specialists may do some cosmetic surgery if it falls within their ambit, for example, eye surgeons could do cosmetic eyelid surgery, ENT surgeons can do cosmetic ear surgery or nose jobs.
Some “cosmetic surgeons” have done a surgical training, but again, the HPCSA states that surgeons may only work in their scope, that ongoing training and education are maintained, etc. General surgeons performing breast augmentation are generally unacceptable.
5. Choosing the Right Surgeon
What guidance would you give patients to ensure they select the right surgeon for their procedure?
Dr Ngwenya advises:
Do your due diligence! Social media is not the official database for registered Plastic Surgeons, and the number of followers does not translate to/nor correlate with legitimacy and competence.
Search and verify their registration with the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA).
Other useful platforms, as mentioned above, are member bodies such as APRASSA and/or ISAPS.
Remember: most reputable hospitals around South Africa will generally only allow qualified specialists within their premises; verification as per the aforementioned is still imperative.
Dr Lazarus also provided this helpful page link.
In closing… Why the scope of practice matters for every patient
1. Scope Awareness
Why is it important for patients to understand each practitioner’s scope of practice before undergoing a procedure?
Dr Lazarus explains:
To prevent harm.
APRASSA is seeing an increasing number of complications (botched) surgery arising from non-specialist-performed cosmetic surgery. These include unfavourable outcomes, bleeding, sepsis and infection, and various serious complications resulting in ICU admissions and deaths.
Some unqualified practitioners operate in unlicensed facilities without proper anaesthesia, training or oversight.
By contrast, registered plastic surgeons are held to account by a code of ethics and have the knowledge, training, qualifications and registrations which legally allow them to perform cosmetic surgery, generally competently and safely.
2. Professional Bodies and Patient Safety
How do organisations such as the HPCSA, AAMSSA, and APRASSA contribute to patient protection and professional accountability?
Dr Lazarus outlines their roles:
The HPCSA has ethical rules applicable to all health care professionals in this country. These rules apply to the scope of practice, competency and patient care.
APRASSA has stringent criteria for admission, in addition to offering a number of programs:
- A mentoring program for newly qualified surgeons
- Continuing professional development
- Collegial support
- Guidance on ethical issues
Dr Ngwenya adds:
The HPCSA also has the authority to both discipline and deregister a practitioner who is not complying with the rules and regulations set out.
Voluntary bodies such as APRASSA and AAMSSA advocate for the highest practice standards for both members and the profession. Although not regulatory, they raise important matters to the relevant authorities and hold them accountable to their mandate.
Dr Shahien Dollie (AAMSSA) concludes:
Understanding practitioner scope protects patients from unsafe providers, unregulated treatments and inappropriate procedures in unsafe environments, as well as misrepresentation by practitioners using misleading titles.
Clear knowledge of accreditation ensures that patients receive care appropriate to their needs and clinical risks, thus avoiding complications and suboptimal outcomes.
Organisations such as the HPCSA, AAMSSA, and APRASSA help to ensure accountability, transparency, and patient protection across the aesthetic and surgical fields.
Final thought
Ultimately, understanding the scope of practice is not about titles — it is about safety, training, and appropriate care.
When patients take the time to verify qualifications and choose the right practitioner for the right procedure, outcomes improve, and risks are significantly reduced.
In a field that continues to evolve rapidly, informed decisions remain one of the most powerful tools a patient has.
About the author
Paola Chellew is a freelance journalist and regularly writes for a number of publications. A former professional contemporary dancer, she has always loved the arts in all their forms. She has been a freelance writer for many years and has been published in various magazines including Live Out Loud, Private Life and Do It now magazines. Her passion for beauty and skincare started in her teens, when she would read every beauty editor’s picks and reviews. Serious about skincare, she has researched medical-grade products for over ten years, as well as aesthetic treatments to restore and repair skin to look its best. Since entering her 60s, she has dedicated her blog to the “over 50s and beyond Club”, shining a spotlight on a generation that is seemingly sidelined by the beauty industry. “There is no age limit for when you stop being beautiful – a gorgeous lipstick, a sexy fragrance, radiant skin- these are not synonymous with youth- they are just things that add an extra sparkle to my day”.
MBChB (UCT), Adv Dip Aesth Med (FPD).
Dr Dollie has completed multiple hands-on, intense, focussed sessions on facial anatomy, physiology, dermatological pathology, and numerous masterclasses on Non-Surgical Aesthetic Procedures ranging from PLLA suspension sutures to Nanofat/SVF grafting. He is a co-founder and medical director at The Aesthetic Doctors in Nelspruit, South Africa. Dr Dollie enjoys local training in South Africa, attending and has delivered live presentations at local and international aesthetic conferences in Europe, Asia and South Africa, including IMCAS (Paris, Bali, and India), AMWC Monaco, International Kholkida Congress Georgia (Tbilisi). Furthermore, he has authored several aesthetic articles in electronic and print media. Dr Dollie has a passion for education and is an active advocate for the practice of world-class aesthetic medicine on South African shores. He is an executive committee member and serves as treasurer of the Aesthetic and Anti-Ageing Medicine Society of South Africa (AAMSSA).
Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeon | MBChB (UCT), FCS (SA) Plast & Recon Surg
I am a fully qualified specialist Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon, the equivalent of board-certified. I am experienced, having been in private plastic surgery practice since 1998. I focus on Cosmetic Surgery and Aesthetic Procedures.
Professional Affiliations:
- Registered as a specialist Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon with the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA)
- President of the Association of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeons of South Africa (APRASSA) 2024-2026
- Member of the International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (ISAPS)
- International member of the American Society of Plastic Surgery (ASPS)
- Past President and Chair of the South African Cleft Lip and Palate Society (SACLAPS)
- Plastic Surgeon volunteer for Operation Smile
Bsc (Wits). MBBCh (Wits). FCS (SA). FC Plast Surg (SA) MMED General Surgery (UP). MMED Plastic Surgery (UP)
Dr Edward Ngwenya is a Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon, Senior Lecturer (University of Pretoria) as well as a Non-Executive Board Director (South African Medical Association - SAMA). He has a Bachelor of Science (BSc) and Medical degree (MBBCh) from the University of the Witwatersrand, and achieved a Fellowship in Surgery [FCS(SA)] and a Master of Medicine in General Surgery (MMed Surgery) from the University of Pretoria, for which he received the Golden Key award – an award bestowed only to candidates who graduate in the top 15% of the country. He further specialised in the field of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery [FCPlast Surg (SA) and Master of Medicine in Plastic Surgery (MMed Surgery)], which is his current vocation.
Having a double surgical speciality, Dr Ngwenya is thus skilled in diverse surgical procedures and knowledgeable as an authority in his field. His interests include, but are not limited to, Breast Surgery (Cosmetic and Reconstructive), Body contouring (body shaping procedures), Onco-plastics (Cancer surgery), and Aesthetic Surgery.
Dr Ngwenya is a member of APRASSA, ISAPS and serves as a committee member of AAMSSA.




